When I started blogging, I made it a point to cover some tea recipes that weren’t the most traditional. Many assumed that since I had a tea food blog, finger sandwich recipes would be in plenty. For the most part, I chose to hold off on tea sandwiches for a while, just until I could give you the perfect tea sandwich bread recipe to get things rolling.
This Tea Sandwich Loaf recipe is adapted from Nancy Silverton and Teri Gelber’s incredible cookbook, Nancy Silverton’s Sandwich Book. The bread made from this recipe yields the soft, tender, tight-crumbed bread that we’ve come to associate with a scrumptious tea sandwich. After all, a tea sandwich can only be as delicious as the bread is.
There are many wonderful things about making tea sandwich bread at home. First (and most obviously), nothing beats a golden loaf of bread baking in your oven. In the fall and wintertime, the ambient heat from the oven is especially cozy, while the scent of fresh bread instantly makes any place smell like home.
Another less obvious benefit to making tea sandwich bread yourself is that it’s much more versatile than than your standard grocery market loaf. Since it isn’t pre-sliced and has squared edges, you are free to experiment with all kinds of shapes and sizes–a serrated knife or cookie cutter and you are on your way to making some gorgeous tea time delicacies. Thick, thin, rolled, or cubed–the possibilities are endless!
Personally, I love to cut off the crust on this loaf and then slice it thin, lengthwise. By cutting the loaf this way, you’ll be able to make the most of your fillings, where each nibble will have a better (and more equal) filling-to-bread ratio. This is especially great since afternoon tea is such a carb-heavy meal.
In my family, I’m a crustless kind of gal, while my mom loves the crisp, golden edges on a fresh loaf. The crust on this bread is like the crust on a rustic French bread. You can’t go wrong with a dab of European butter or jam. Above all, the trick here is to not slice (or eat) the bread until it has cooled completely…take my word for it, you might want to make two loaves just in case!
Looking for an elegant tea to enjoy with a slice of this delicious bread? My suggestion is a decadent vanilla bean Darjeeling blend called I’ll Take You There…a tea blended by the co-author of Nancy Silverton’s Sandwich Book, my friend Teri Gelber!
Tea Sandwich Bread
Makes 1 large loaf.
1 1/3 cups lukewarm water
2 1/4 tsp SAF instant yeast
3 3/4 cups + 1 Tbsp bread flour
1 Tbsp powdered nonfat milk
1 Tbsp + 1 tsp sugar
2 tsp salt
3 Tbsp unsalted butter, softened
1 Tbsp melted butter or non-stick spray, for coating bowl and pan
large stand mixer with dough hook attachment
pullman loaf pan (13″ or 12 cup capacity)
serrated bread knife (if slicing)
cooking thermometer (optional)
bread slicer (optional)
1.) Make the Dough. Place the yeast, bread flour, powdered milk, and sugar in the mixing bowl of a large stand mixer. Turn the mixer on low-speed, then add the water. Increase the speed to medium, then mix for 2 minutes. After two minutes, turn off the mixer and then add the salt. Turn the mixer on low again to incorporate the salt, then increase the mixer to medium speed once again. Add the softened butter, 1 Tbsp at a time, then continue to mix the dough for about 10 minutes. When you add the butter, the dough will make a slapping sound against the side of the mixing bowl like when you make a brioche dough.
2.) First Rise. After 10 minutes you should get a soft and supple ball of dough. Place the dough in a bowl lightly greased with melted butter or nonstick spray. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap, then place in a warm, draft free place to rise until doubled in volume.
3.) Shape the Loaf. After doubling in volume, place the dough on a work surface, then give the dough a few light kneadings. Lightly pull/press the dough to make an evenly thick 8″ x 11″ rectangle (like a piece of paper). Fold the left and right sides over lengthwise to meet in the middle (the sides should overlap). Square off the edges, then pinch the seam closed. Tuck, pinch, and seal off the ends under the long loaf.
4.) Second Rise. Place the cylinder-like loaf seam side down, into a pullman pan greased with melted butter or nonstick spray. Let the dough rest in the pan for about 5 minutes (covered with plastic wrap), then use your fingers to press the dough into the pan as evenly as possible–this will help to assure squared off edges on the loaf when it bakes. Cover the loaf pan with plastic wrap, then place in a warm, draft free place until it rises to 1/2″ under the top edge of the pan.
5.) Bake, Cool, and Slice! About a half hour before the loaf has finished rising, place an oven rack in the lower 1/3 portion of your oven, then heat the oven to 475 degrees F. When the dough has risen (1/2″ under the rim), slide the greased top of the pullman loaf pan on. Bake the loaf for about 45 minutes, until the loaf is golden brown or registers an internal temperature of 190 degrees F on a cooking thermometer. Wait until the bread completely cools before slicing with a serrated knife.
Adapted from Tea Sandwich Loaf recipe in Nancy Silverton’s Sandwich Book by Nancy Silverton and Teri Gelber.
I like your bread slice guide! Have been looking for something like that but can’t seem to find it here in the UK. Yours looks great, do you mind me asking where you got it from?
Hey there! So the brand of my bread slicer is Bread Pal…http://www.breadpal.net…not sure if they ship to the UK, but if you look on Amazon for “bread slicer” you should find some good options (that’s how I found mine). It’s very useful, especially if you make homemade bread frequently. Hope this helps! 🙂
This one looks exactly what I was looking for, other models are too flimsy or plasticky…
It looks like Amazon UK doesn’t sell it at the moment, but Breadpal seems to ship to the UK so will investigate!
This bread looks sensational – perfect white sandwich bread. It makes me want to run out and buy a pullman loaf pan!
Do it Monica! 🙂 The pan is very fun to bake with! 😉
Your load is perfectly flat on top, how do you manage to do that? Is it to do with the tin?
Hi Sam! So another name for this bread loaf is a pullman loaf or pan di mie loaf. It has this characteristic shape (squared angles and flat sides) because of the pan that’s used to make it. In the photos, I don’t have the top of the pan pictured, but the pan lid is actually placed on right before the risen, shaped dough goes in the oven…kind of like a “ceiling” so that the bread can’t rise past the lip of the pan…the result is that the crumb of the bread is a bit tighter than usual. It’s really fun to bake with…hope you can try sometime! 🙂 Thanks for stopping by!
Wow! That’s a neat little kitchen gadget! Thanks for taking the time to explain Bonnie. It’s one less culinary mystery for me to ponder about. Quite a simple idea really… I wonder if the same kind of tins exist for cakes?! They must do… Anyway, thanks again! 🙂
Bonnie! These pictures are incredible and so is this loaf! Loving your posts lately. They are super creative!
Thank you so much Chaya! Creativity is a weird thing–sometimes it works, and sometimes it’s just plain strange! 🙂
What a beauty !…going to try thisfor sure.
Hope you love it girl–can’t beat fresh bread! 🙂
your loaf pan is adorable! like you, i like my sandwiches crustless but my frugal heart can’t handle throwing out the crusts… until i came up with the solution of just grinding them to make bread crumbs. crisis averted!
I do the same thing Lan! Making homemade bread takes a good amount of effort, so every crumb must be used. 🙂
I have never made my own sandwich bread before! Now that I’ve seen your recipe Bonnie, I definitely will never be store buying a loaf again. Thanks for the inspiration!
It’s really very easy to make as long as you have a mixer! Let me know how it turns out Thalia! 😉
This bread looks so professional!
Thank you so much Maria!! 🙂
That bread loaf looks amazing Bonnie! So photogenic and golden brown on the outside as you can tell I like the crust on bread 😉
Agree! Crust is delish, and this one looks so appetizing!
Thank you so much Maria!! Fresh bread is the best isn’t it? 😉
Oh my gosh this bread looks perfect! So fluffy and white 🙂 Now i’m really craving high tea!
Thank you so much Lillian! I’m always in the mood for afternoon tea! 🙂
wow – this loaf is pure and simple perfection! Beautiful!
Thank you so much Afra!! 😉
The loaf is beautifully baked! I totally agree with you that the freshly baked bread is the best and it’s so versatile! Pinned!
Thank you so much Maggie…hope you can try sometime!! 😉
This loaf looks absolutely wonderful. And I’m not even a bread person but I know I would love this
Thank you Miss K! The bread is fluffy and light, perfect for those who aren’t fond of heavier loaves. 🙂
Reblogged this on kiadabomb_Cupcakes and commented: